First things first: When Mrs. Butcher and I go on our fishing trips to the fish market, we always buy them out of what are called “scallop pieces.” These are basically whole scallops that got cut the wrong way when harvesting so they don’t look perfect—and they sell for way less than the perfect scallops. This time, however, we didn’t come home with nearly as many as before, so we’ll probably have to go on another fishing trip in a few months when the wild salmon are in season.
A caveat before we get started: I had no idea if the pesto and lemon would work together or clash horribly. The good news is that it worked, so here we are. I have no measurements for this because I was just throwing shit together to see what would happen.
Here’s what you’ll need:
Fettucine
Olive Oil
Butter – about a ¼ of a stick
1 Small Onion, diced
Lemon Juice – about a ¼ cup
Salt and Pepper
2-4 Cloves Garlic, grated
Scallops – about a pound
Freshly grated Romano cheese
Pesto – about a ⅓ of a cup
Start by boiling your salted water and throwing the fettuccine in there. Stir it around for the first couple of minutes because fettuccine likes to stick together. Do not put oil in the water. That shit is for amateurs. Then stir the fettuccine every couple of minutes until done.
While the fettuccine is cooking, heat the oil and butter over medium and sauté the onions for a few minutes, until translucent.

Then add the lemon juice, salt and pepper, garlic and scallops. Turn off the heat but leave the pot on the burner and cover. Stir every 30 seconds or so for 2-4 minutes or until scallops are done, then remove from the heat so they don’t become rubber balls.

When the fettuccine is ready, reserve about a ¼ to ½ cup of the pasta water and drain the rest out. Mix the fettuccine with the reserved pasta water, pesto and Romano cheese until thoroughly mixed and slightly creamy looking.

Then toss the scallop mixture in there and mix well.
Serve in bowls, preferably with a crusty sourdough bread (I didn’t have any on hand at the time and I am all the poorer for it.) and a little extra Romano on top.
This is awesome. How do I know this, aside from my own unassailable sense of taste? Because Mrs. Butcher has asked that it be made again in the near future.
Oh man. That looks really good!
I would eat the whole bowl.
I almost did. It was a struggle to set some aside for the next day.
I love all seafood and I think scallops/scaaallops/scahllops are my favorite most of all. I find them very filling, though. Did you and the Missus get through all the scallops and fettuccine? No doubt the two of us would, but we are
gluttonsgourmands.I just made scallops last Friday for the weekly Pescatarian Observance. I had had a long week so I just cooked the scallops through, that takes very little time/effort, boiled some spaghetti, and reheated and re-garlicked some leftover marinara sauce. Deelish. When I’m out of crusty bread I just toast whatever we have lying around and it’s not a bad substitute, as long as it not WonderBread or something.
Nope, we resisted the urge to gorge ourselves and had the rest the next day.
Mmmm. Sometimes “winging it” recipes are the very best. Again, I ask, do you deliver?
Only to the dinner table.
So the first time I had scallops was about 18 months ago, when on a drunk cousins movie night, my cousin pulled some bacon-wrapped frozen scallops from Aldi and baked them.
Which, amazing.
And then about a year ago when I was in Oregon for a trip, I went to an overpriced yet amazing restaurant and had the bay scallop appetizer as basically a meal. I regret nothing.
Well, that’s a lie.
I regret that I only had the one meal at that restaurant.