Tastes Like Chicken? [NOT 22/11/24]

woman attacking alligator
A Tongariferous Fight With an Alligator / 1837 / source: https://www.loc.gov/item/2003663568/

This For That

Thanksgiving in the US is approaching, and the smell of poultry will soon be in the air.

OR WILL IT?

As we all know, it’s become a joke just how often people claim things that aren’t chicken taste just like chicken. Rattlesnake, possum, WHO KNOWS? So let’s talk about substitutes of all kinds of things.

How do you feel about pleather, for example? I’m not terribly concerned about high quality leather, and I’m OK with decent quality fake leather shoes. I’ve seen some Doc Martens with pleather which seem quite nice.

Tofu hotdogs taste like garbage to me, but Impossible Burgers are halfway decent. Imitation vanilla extract, no thank you. On the other hand, I don’t have a problem with store brand cola instead of Coke or Pepsi.

Hen & Chickens / 1901 / source: https://www.loc.gov/item/2018757362/

So let us know if you have any substitutes which you like, or which are even indistinguishable from the original. Lemmy might have a concerns with me saying this, but I don’t have an issue in general with swapping out one type of whiskey for another, unless maybe it’s peated single malt Scotch.

For that matter, do you have a strong allegiance to turkey for Thanksgiving? If someone served rotisserie chicken from the store, would you care?

Mythbusters even ran a blind taste test of things like frog and snake to see if they tasted like chicken, and the answer was (almost always) no.

No right or wrong answers and of course if there’s a different subject for Open Threading you think is just as good, by all means substitute it here.

avataravataravataravataravataravataravatar

17 Comments

  1. Once our Thanksgivings shrunk to a small number pf attendees, turkey no longer made sense to make. So I’m cool with whatever. I don’t want to be stuck with 5 lbs of leftover bland turkey to try to use up somehow.

  2. Depends on the item.

    Cheap stuff rarely is a substitute for the good stuff, but sometimes that’s all you got and one has gotta make do.

    But sometimes, if your buddies travel all the way from the west coast to Toronto and you drive all of them to Kingston aka K-Town to relive your past and the gang goes to eat at a diner that was famous for putting chicken soup mix (Lipton or no name) on their fries instead of salt AND THEY DON’T, well it’s a total fucking goddamned bummer then there is no fucking substitute!!!*

    I want my MSG!

    *the next place we hit turned out to have the fries we were looking for. MSG fix done. For a moment, I was ready to hit the nearest bulk food store to buy some soup mix (no noodles) and pour it on my fries. No, I don’t make it a regular thing with my own home fries because I like having normal blood pressure.

  3. When my daughter stopped eating meat I had to substitute vegetarian options in some of her favorite dishes I make.  I have found some vegetarian chorizo is better than the meat version.  I had a vegetarian chicken & waffles in Vegas that was as good as any real chicken version I have ever had.

  4. some of the veggie fake chicken bits actually taste like chicken once pan fried nowadays…right texture too

    if you marinade them with a lil char siu sauce before pan frying them they turn out straight delicious

Leave a Reply